My love/hate relationship with the funnel.

I have a complicated relationship with the marketing funnel. On one hand, I love it. It’s elegant. It’s simple. And it’s one of the most useful and illustrative conceptual models our industry has ever produced.

On the other hand, I HATE IT. Not because it’s wrong, but because it’s woefully incomplete. And we’ve been teaching it, illustrating it, and building marketing plans around it for more than a century without bothering to fix one rather glaring omission.

A little history. The marketing funnel has been around for a long time. Its origins date back more than 100 years, when advertising pioneer Elias St. Elmo Lewis introduced the principles that eventually evolved into the four-stage A-I-D-A model we use today: Awareness, Interest, Desire, Action. (Technically, Lewis’ first A stood for Attention, but the underlying idea about moving through these stages was quite similar.)

The concept is beautifully simple, logical, and easy to understand. And when you visualize that progression as a funnel, it gets even better. The wide opening at the top represents the universe of consumers who might become aware of your brand. As they progress through the stages, the funnel narrows, illustrating perhaps the most important reality: not everyone who becomes aware will become interested. Not everyone who’s interested will develop desire. And not everyone who desires your product will take action.

There’s leakage at every stage. And this is why the conceptual model is so useful. [Sidebar: There are a lot of people out there who genuinely think that reaching a million people with an ad campaign means that a million people will suddenly consider buying your product. Your current client is probably one of them.]

The funnel, as a model, helps us understand how marketing impacts consumers and their perceptions over time. It also reminds us that the job of marketing is mostly about progressively creating the appropriate conditions for consumers to make decisions.

The funnel is also one of the best teaching tools in the business. In fact, I use it with my grad students every semester. However, the tragic flaw of the funnel is that it treats the action as the finale. And that’s where the “hate” part of my love/hate relationship with the funnel strolls onto the stage.

Here’s why. The A-I-D-A model simply ends at action. And then, nothing. It’s like “YAY! We did it! We got a consumer to take an action! We’ve reached the bottom of the funnel! Order the pizza and beer and then let’s take the afternoon off!” It has that “Mission Accomplished” ethos written all over it. It’s ridiculous.

First, let’s consider what “action” actually means. It might mean visiting a website. Or downloading a PDF. Or offering up an email address. It doesn’t always mean making a purchase, or an initial appointment. And as we all know, downloading a PDF, while a cute KPI, is not going to get your client renewing your budget for next year. The marketing job is not done when someone reads your e-book, bro.

Now let’s assume that the action is indeed a purchase. The consumer has navigated through all four stages, chosen your brand over the competition, and handed over some hard-earned money. That’s a win.

But what happens next? Do we simply display the thank you page, wave goodbye, and turn our attention to the next batch of unsuspecting prospects? Of course not. That would be marketing malpractice, especially because you’d be abandoning the relationship right at the moment when it’s become most valuable.

In fairness, smart marketers have understood the importance of retention, loyalty, repeat purchase, and advocacy for decades. And many funnel-faithful marketers include some of these things, but they tend to do so outside of the model. That stuff happens on a different floor of the building. So, if we’re willing to admit that there’s usually more to the conceptual story, why do we keep leaving out the last chapter? That’s like having Freebird or Hotel California, but without the guitar solos at the end.

Models matter. Especially the ones that are being taught in both undergrad and grad schools. They influence how we think, what tactics we may prioritize, and ultimately, where we may spend our marketing dollars. The funnel is so ubiquitous that we now have acronyms like TOFU, MOFU and BOFU (which all sound silly to me, by the way) to represent top-of-funnel, middle-of-funnel and bottom-of-funnel activities. So, when something this popular and widely utilized under-represents the whole story, I think we’re doing the industry a disservice by perpetuating it. We have to illustrate what happens next, and include it as an essential element of the model.

So I propose a modest addition to the venerable AIDA framework. Let’s call it AIDAI. Just add another “I” at the end. And it stands for Involvement.

The idea is simple: after a consumer takes action, marketers should be working just as hard to encourage continued involvement with the brand as they worked to generate awareness, interest, desire, and action in the first place. Some of that involvement is practical. Product updates. Warranty information. Service reminders. Helpful content that makes the product easier or more enjoyable to use. And when that initial action is NOT a purchase, involvement can keep the brand top of mind for a consumer who has expressed some level of interest. A well-conceived brand app can be an excellent example of the “I” part of the funnel in action.

Consider Starbucks. Its app (and the embedded rewards program) provides ongoing reasons and avenues for customers to continually interact with the brand, accumulate benefits, explore offers, and return for future purchases. It also does not require a purchase…you can download the Starbucks app even if you’ve never purchased. (And that download, interestingly, is an action that might ultimately lead to a first purchase!)

BMW offers “Performance Driving Schools” across the country, where they offer classroom lessons and driving classes, including for teens. BMW extends the purchase of your vehicle by showing you how to take the “ultimate driving machine” and learn how to drive it as such. But here’s the cool part: You don’t need to be a BMW owner to participate. The “action” here is simply showing interest. (And note how compelling it might be to sit behind the wheel of an M5 and drive it like a race car.)

Other brands go even further and create opportunities for purchasers to not only continue interacting with the brand, but also to interact with other purchasers. Jeep and Harley-Davidson, for example, offer opportunities for owners to participate in events, to organize group rides, and to form communities that reinforce the emotional connection between consumer and brand.

These aren’t merely clever promotional tactics. (I mean, they are.) They’re deliberate efforts to extend the customer relationship beyond an initial action, even if that action is an expression of interest. And they work in different ways, across different categories, for different reasons.

Now, let’s be clear. Not every brand can take advantage of these opportunities. I can’t imagine a meetup of enthusiastic toilet paper purchasers getting together for extreme wiping lessons. But the potential is there in different ways, and every brand should be asking what meaningful ongoing involvement might look like.

And that’s my beef with the current four-stage funnel. It simply ends. And that’s why I not only think that Involvement should be the fifth stage, but I also think it should shift the way the model flows. Once added, it creates a continuous loop stage between Action and Involvement. It looks like this:

The brand actively encourages involvement. Involvement stimulates additional actions. Those actions create opportunities for deeper involvement. And around we go.

And the additional action does not necessarily have to be a repeat purchase. (Although that’s delicious.) Sometimes it’s participation in an event. Sometimes it’s sharing content, or offering a testimonial, or recommending the brand, or simply choosing to stay connected in various ways. But here’s the quiet part that I’ll say out loud. Continued involvement can reinforce preference, reduce perceived risk and ultimately create deeper trust. Which implies that future actions may not require the same journey through awareness/interest/desire. The relationship itself has changed, and illustrates that nice, neat, linear funnels are not so linear after all.

I’m not suggesting we abandon the traditional funnel. I’m suggesting that we finish it, and avoid ending with a splat. Because the job of marketing isn’t simply to move consumers from awareness to action. It should be to create and sustain valuable relationships that encourage consumers to keep acting, interacting, participating, advocating, and yes, even keep purchasing when that’s appropriate too.

Dunkin’ Is Nuts

The news has officially come down, (although it’s been in the works for almost a year,) that Dunkin’ Donuts, the international (yes, they have stores in 36 countries,) brand that was established nearly 70 years ago, is changing its name.25_Dunkin_Before_After_c4885e75-fe56-4add-aab3-a51120689229-prv

They will no longer be Dunkin’ Donuts, but will officially change their name to simply Dunkin’ as of January, 2019. According to the company’s official press release, the plan behind this switch is to transform the company into a “beverage-led, on-the-go” brand.

To cut to the chase, this is a bad idea. A really bad idea.

Let’s start at the beginning. Dunkin’ Donuts dominates in the donut category, leading Krispy Kreme and Mister Donut by a long way, and by a wide margin in terms of number of stores.

The brand also competes in the coffee category, and meets a strong and persistent consumer need in that area. And for decades, Dunkin’ Donuts coffee has established itself as unique, based on flavor profile (and, some would argue, sheer temperature.)

As the quick-serve coffee category has expanded in the last 20-30 years, and has come to be dominated by Starbucks, Dunkin’ Donuts has pivoted to offer more varieties and flavors of coffee and espresso drinks, and has achieved a strong challenger position. According to Statista, Starbucks has almost double the market share volume over Dunkin’ Donuts in this category, and slightly more than all others combined (not including Dunkin’ Donuts.)

So if you’re a challenger brand in any category (and this has turned into a classic leader/challenger category like Coke/Pepsi or McDonald’s/Burger King,) your goal as a brand should never be to appear MORE like the leader. The goal is to establish difference.

And DONUTS is what makes this brand special.
DONUTS is what makes this brand DIFFERENT.

Now, the Dunkin’ brand will still carry donuts.  But when you don’t tell people that it’s what makes you different, (say, by including “donuts” in your brand name,) who’s to say that consumers will inherently know? Especially young, entering-the-market consumers who may not be familiar with the brand’s history?  What will Dunkin’ mean 10 or 20 years from now without context?

The idea of changing the name to Dunkin’ at all seems wholly misdirected.  When the press release states that you want to be a more “beverage-led” brand, the slang word “Dunkin'” doesn’t say “beverages” at all.  What’s more insulting is that the name referred to the verb of actually. dunking. donuts. in. coffee.

So let’s review:  Dunkin’ Donuts is perceptually and verbally moving AWAY from the category they dominate, and CLOSER to a category where they challenge a leader who owns nearly twice the market share, and where their only competitive advantage is average price.  Sounds like a frozen-double-mocha mistake in judgment to me.

Dunkin’ (as they will be called in a few months,) should stick to what they’re good at – good coffee and family-friendly offerings served in modest stores at moderate pricing. AND LOTS AND LOTS OF DONUTS.

 

 

 

 

The Law of Constant Improvement

In marketing, most brands that are enjoying success are likely doing so because they created something that WORKS. Whether it’s a consumer product like a vacuum cleaner that never loses suction, or the standard-setter in smartphones or a business-to-business service like an ad network or a social media platform or even a service provider like an ad agency or web development firm, something is WORKING. It could be the product design, or the solution to a common problem, or a specific process or a recipe or even an algorithm.

But what’s the secret sauce that KEEPS brands thriving? How do we move from enjoying just a modicum of success to relishing a systematic pattern of victories and enduring prosperity? While some may chalk it up to luck or a charismatic CEO or market timing, I assert that the most successful and most profitable brands in every corner of the marketing world all share a similar trait: they employ the Law of Constant Improvement.

When brands (in virtually any category) are thriving, it’s typically due to a combination of factors that include the basic food groups: an ability to deliver [manufacture/write/uncover/sing/whatever] something of value, an understanding of the market environment, an understanding of the target consumer needs, an understanding of limitations and mandatories, and so on. But the lasting effects of excellence are usually garnered by a sustained and even obstinate desire to continue improving on current successes.

The Law of Constant Improvement states that you are never quite “there” yet. While you may be enjoying success (and profits,) there is no qualifying reason to halt the process of improvement. And in this law, improvement is not one-sided. Normally, we would focus on the consumer audience, and how to make the product/experience/service better for them. But brands can constantly improve internally, [financially, operationally, culturally, philanthropically] as well. This is true if you run a small business, a large corporation, a non-profit or a community. It’s especially true if you’re in marketing.

A healthy side effect of The Law of Constant Improvement seems to be a proclivity towards extended tenure. It becomes evident when you review success stories in almost any category: a technology leader like Apple; an online leader like Amazon; a consumer leisure brand [or is it a retail experience? or is it a coffee shop?] like Starbucks; a band like Coldplay.  All seem to factor a common denominator: they are constantly striving to improve. And it doesn’t have to be big, blue-chip brand business: local and regional marketers can employ the same law, and alter their DNA to replicate success. The evidence seems to suggest that brands who continue to improve with a near-obsessive regularity become leaders.

Another aspect of The Law of Constant Improvement is its ability to permeate into the corporate culture. It’s clear that brands who adopt a process of constant improvement don’t do so as a line item operational procedure, but rather because it’s embedded into the personality of the company, and into the personality of each employee. It turns out that constant improvement is less a thing to do, and more a thing to be.

Also note that in the inner gears of today’s consumer-centric commerce machine, the market has come to DEMAND constant improvement. That’s just the new rules at play. There’s so much competition and customization out there that brands have to continue to evolve each product and feature to keep their audience(s) engaged and entertained.

It would likely be a lot easier to happen on a formula and then just keep churning it out for eternity. (Note, for some brands, that’s a solid strategy – see Coke vs. the New Coke debacle.) But for the vast majority of brands, The Law of Constant Improvement is the new mandatory to continue to engage your original audience, to roll up new fans, to outperform expectations and if you fit into this category, to satisfy shareholders.

So start improving today. And be prepared to never stop.